Tamp&Puff member-recommended eBay sellers →  bobus  •  great estate-pipes  •  Judd  •  irishlefty  •  knobby  •  pipestud  •  shiny pipes  •  secondhandsmoker

Jim's D&R Reviews.

Discuss specific pipe tobaccos in detail and post your reviews here.

Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby JimInks » Thu May 28, 2015 1:14 am

Here are my reviews of the Daughters & Ryan blends I have tried. I know some think that most of their blends are “roll your own”, but I have found that’s not necessarily true. While some easily fall into that category, a number of them do not, and all are worth smoking in a pipe. Many of them are shag cut, and all are dry out of the bag or tin, so I always recommend a slow puffing cadence when you smoke them, though I prefer hydrated tobacco. You’re not paying for water weight. Many of these blends have no casings or toppings, so you can expect true tobacco flavor in most of these products.


Athey:
The Virginia is grassy, hay-like, and citrusy sweet with a slight honey note, and stands out beyond what else you will taste. All the toppings are very mild, with the molasses being more noticeable than the others. The Scotch/Drambuie is lightly, sweetly evident, and I don’t know what the “light botanical topping” is, but the slight floral essence from it plays well with the other flavors as does every other one I previously noted. Has a mild to medium nic-hit. Burns fast but cool with a consistent flavor, no moisture and a pleasing after taste. A nice work and play smoke.

Avanti:
I don’t get any vanilla from the black cavendish, so it must be unsweetened. The double toasted burley is indeed toasty and nutty with a slight sharpness. The Virginias are grass and hay with some natural sweetness. Blender Mark Ryan said that there are “seven proprietary toppings that I am not at liberty to disclose.” Toppings are, next to orientals, the hardest thing to figure out most of the time, and I can’t figure out which ones this product uses. They do somewhat sublimate the tobacco taste. I sense both a dry and a sweet wine, and something that gives a feel of alcohol. I’m thinking both red and white wine are in the mix, particularly the latter. I’m no liquor expert, but the presence of one or more is obvious to me, and I suspect drambuie is one of them. I also get a hint of orange and a slight floral essence. Burns at a moderate pace with a sweet, consistent flavor like none I’ve ever tasted in a tobacco blend. A smooth, cool and dry smoke that leaves virtually no moisture in the bowl. Has a little nicotine, and a nice after taste and room note.

Cockstrong:
The burley is the star component: toasty, nutty and oat-like, with a little sharp earthiness and a touch of sweetness. The flue cured gold leaf is grassy with a touch of citrus. The Orientals are dry, woody, and lightly smoky. There are no toppings. I did encounter a few cigarette notes along the way, but it didn’t detract from the experience. You’ll notice all the flavors in every puff. Burns well with almost or no relights, and leaves no moisture. Has a very noticeable nic-hit. Performs best when smoked slowly. Though it isn’t as strong as the name may indicate, it’s just over the all day smoke threshold.

English Hoopla:
The Cyprian latakia is smoky, woody with a mild sweetness. The Oriental is woody with a slight sour note, a little earth, and toward the finish, seems to have a spice note. The Virginia is grassy, citrusy sweet, and acts as the base for the other components to play off. It’s the least noticeable of the three tobaccos. Even though the latakia takes the lead over the other ingredients, it doesn’t over take the Oriental and Virginia. The anisette and vanilla toppings are lightly applied, with the former being a little more obvious than the latter. Both are smooth with some creaminess, and they do not detract from the flavors of the tobaccos. Has a moderate nic-hit. Well balanced, it burns at a moderate pace with very few relights with a cool consistency, and leaves virtual no moisture in the bowl.

London Dock:
The double toasted burley is the basic star; toasty, a little sweet, grassy, earthy and nutty. The Virginia is citrus, grass and hay. The Oriental offers a sour note and wood in a minor way. The perique is slightly noticeable with spice, and a touch of raisins and figs. The coumarin is very slightly vanilla-like, and adds a nice floral context. The rum is very mild and sweet. Well balanced with a nice complexity, it has a very consistent flavor from the first puff to the last one, but needs to be smoked at a slow to moderate pace to catch them all. Burns well and cool with no dull or harsh spots (unless you puff fast), and leaves no moisture. Three and a half stars, though I am tempted to give it four.

Ramback Regular:
The Turkish is choice: fairly woody, earthy, and toasty, slightly floral and spicy, with a few sweet and sour notes. There are no toppings, and the cut is closer to shag than ribbon. Dry as are all the D&R blends, it burns quickly and can be harsh if you puff fast. Not very nuanced as it is a straight Turkish, and not an all day smoke, but it does well in small to medium doses. Has some nicotine, leaves no moisture. It reminds me a little of smoking a Camel cigarette in your pipe, and if you like that, you’ll like this. Would make a good mixer, too.

Rimboche A.B.:
The first thing that hit my taste buds was the tangy spice from the dark fired tobacco that was processed by the perique method. It is a little raisiny, figgy, smoky and woody, too. There’s a “touch” of latakia present, but noticeable in most every puff and adds a sweet, very smoky, woodiness. I think more than a touch is present, but the latakia always plays back up. The flue cured gold Virginias are the base for the other components to shine; grassy and hay-like with some citrus and a drop or two of honey. Has no toppings. Very well balanced with a consistent flavor to the finish. Leaves no moisture. It does benefit a little from some hydration, but it does very well dry, and isn’t really necessary due to the richness of flavors. And I seldom smoke bone dry tobacco. Has a nice nic-hit. Will not bite, but the spice is pleasantly tingly all the way, including the after taste.

Rimboche, S.J.:
The Virginia is grassy sweet with some citrus and a touch of honey. The Saint James perique is more plumy sweet than peppery in a very complimentary supporting role, and is noticeable in every puff. There are no toppings. I suggest you hydrate this one first, but if you don’t, it’ll burn fairly quickly without harshness, unless you puff like a winded Superman after a race. The flavor is consistent with a decent nic-hit, and leaves no moisture in the bowl. An all day smoke for the VaPer aficionado who wants a break from heavier blends in this genre.

Rowland Regular:
The Virginia is grassy, citrusy sweet with a drop of honey. The burley is nutty, toasty sweet and well complements the Virginia without over taking it. The Oriental is a minor component, very slightly spicy, smoky and woody. The very light chocolate topping is mildly sweet, and doesn’t detract from the tobacco taste. It has a mellowing affect that smooths out the blend. Burns well and cool with hardly a relight, no moisture, and a consistent flavor. Has a slightly more than mild nic-hit.

Ryback:
The burley is toasty, nutty sweet. The Virginia is grassy, citrus sweet. The dark fired Kentucky is earthy, spicy and slightly woody and sweet. Dry as a bone, and being a shag cut, burns quickly, but not harsh unless you puff it fast. I prefer to hydrate it. The spiciness almost dominates the flavor, though the sweetness of the tobaccos is right there to compliment and contrast it. No casing or topping. Has a fair amount of nicotine. Leaves no moisture and if you like this kind of tobacco, you will appreciate the after taste.

Three Sails:
A simple uncomplicated Virginia with natural citrusy sweetness and some grassiness. Reminds me exactly of Three Castles, which I used to enjoy, and I suspect this is what the Castles once was. I also get a few familiar notes that reminds me of Sir Walter Raleigh Aromatic. I'm not comparing those two blends because they are different (e.g., SWRA has a topping and burley, and this has neither), but they both must use a similar type of Virginia. Puff at a slow to moderate rate, and Three Sails will do well, won’t bite or get harsh or amazingly cigarette-like, though you’ll get some of the latter no matter how slow you puff. Puff fast, and you risk all of that and more. Leaves no moisture, and being a dry shag cut, burns quickly, but not hot if you pace the smoke. Has a nice nic-note.

Two Timer:
The burley is toasty, and very nutty with natural sweetness. While it may be used as a RYO, it’s a good smoke with a little nicotine punch. Puffed at a moderate rate, it’ll mostly keep its flavor and not get harsh. Puffed fast, it’ll have some cigarette notes, a little loss of flavor and possibly some harshness. Has no casing or topping. Burns quickly, but not hot, clean with no moisture and some nicotine. Nice, uncomplicated all day smoke that does even better with some hydration.

Two Timer Gold:
This is Two Timer with Virginia, and with that exception, the smoking qualities are the same. The burley is toasty, and very nutty with natural sweetness. The Virginia is a little grassy with some citrus and a touch of honey. While it may be used as a RYO, it’s a good smoke with a little nicotine punch. Puffed at a moderate rate, it’ll mostly keep its flavor and not get harsh. Puffed fast, it’ll have some cigarette notes, a little loss of flavor and possibly some harshness. Has no casing or topping. Burns quickly, but not hot, clean with no moisture. Nice, uncomplicated all day smoke that does even better with some hydration.

Vengeur Regular:
The flue-cured Virginia is grassy and mildly sweet with a touch of citrus. The burley is a little toasty, nutty, but has very little sweetness. The Oriental is slightly floral and woody in a supporting role. A thin ribbon cut that burns fairly quickly, this needs to be sipped to avoid harshness, and provide a smooth smoke. Leaves no moisture and has a mild to medium nic-hit. Has no casing or topping. I recommend a little hydration as the tobacco is very dry, which will enhance the flavors a bit. An all day smoke that wears well in repeat performances.

VIP:
The light and brown Virginias are buttery sweet with a hint of grass and earth, and some citrus. The smell of the tobacco from an open tin is fruity: apricots, figs and raisins, and much of that is mildly evident in the smoke. The perique is more fruity than peppery, but the latter is an important part of the experience. The tobacco is dry out of the tin, so you may prefer to hydrate it. I found the flavors stood out more when I did. Burns well, cool and very smooth with a consistent flavor, no dottle, and no chance of bite. The sweet taste never wanes or gets boring, and the after taste pleasantly lingers long enough for you to immediately considering having another bowl right away. It doesn't have much nicotine, and may not have enough strength satisfy hardcore VaPer smokers, but for those who aren't, it's a four star blend.

William’s Delight:
The double toasted burley is very toasty, and a little sweet, grassy, earthy and nutty. I also got the sense of oats a number of times. There’s not much of the Orientals present, but they are woody, and have a very minor floral and spice hit along with some sourness. The black cavendish is apparently unsweetened, but it adds some smoothness to the tobaccos. The vanilla casing is extremely mild. This is a coarse cut blend that burns at a moderate rate even when dry. And speaking of dry, the light sour dryness throughout the smoke contrasts with the sweet flavors, but has a slight sour, woody bitterness near the finish. That bitterness lingers as in the after taste as does the sweetness. Has some nicotine, leaves no moisture, and while not a powerhouse, I wouldn’t classify this as an all day smoke.
User avatar
JimInks
 
Posts: 14800
Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2013 8:34 pm

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby ratatosk » Thu May 28, 2015 2:17 am

Thanks for the reviews, Jim. Interesting, but the only D&R blend I've actually considered buying is Picayune, mainly out of curiosity. In my wayward youth Picayune cigarettes were the strongest cigarettes made, stronger than Home Runs, and I don't know if they were even sold outside of the South. Managing to smoke a pack was quite a feat for a young lad and, from what I've read, it appears that the pipe blend is intended to be something of a match. :o
Richard
-----------
If even I don't know how many pipes I own, how the hell would you know if I have too many?
User avatar
ratatosk
Supporting Member
Supporting Member
 
Posts: 3594
Joined: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:35 pm
Location: Atlanta

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby JimInks » Tue Dec 15, 2015 8:32 pm

Windsail Original:
A straight uncomplicated flue cured Virginia that is a little grassy and hay-like, and fairly citrusy with some honey and earth notes. It also has a very light spice hit. The nic-hit is just a shade past the mild mark. The strength and taste are medium. Ribbon cut for very easy burning, it requires few relights. Won't bite or get harsh, leaves no moisture in the bowl and will burn to ash with little trouble. Makes tons of smoke. It may be a one dimensional smoke, but it's a very flavorful all day no nonsense blend, and not every pipe tobacco product has to be complex to enjoy. Would make a good mixer, though I prefer to smoke it as it is. I give it three and a half stars out of four.
User avatar
JimInks
 
Posts: 14800
Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2013 8:34 pm

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby KevLa » Wed Dec 16, 2015 6:51 pm

I recently ordered a pound each of Picayune, Rimboché - A.B., and Two Timer - Regular, so these are very useful to me. Thanks, Jim :)
Kev-La :ugeek:__,~
"One being's junk is another's art." Motto of Pipes (Autobot warrior, from Transformers: Generation 1).
User avatar
KevLa
 
Posts: 8878
Joined: Sun Sep 05, 2010 7:45 am
Location: Twelve o' clock high.

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby JimInks » Thu Dec 17, 2015 12:20 am

KevLa wrote:I recently ordered a pound each of Picayune, Rimboché - A.B., and Two Timer - Regular, so these are very useful to me. Thanks, Jim :)


You are very welcome, Kevin. I haven't tried the Picayune, so I'll be interested to hear what you think of it.
User avatar
JimInks
 
Posts: 14800
Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2013 8:34 pm

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby KevLa » Mon Jan 25, 2016 1:27 pm

I'm very much enjoying Rimboché A.B., and concur with your review, Jim, though I haven't tried hydrating it yet. Bags of flavour and quite strong. Easy to light, and little-to-no bite. A great smoke and very affordably priced. I dig it! :)
Kev-La :ugeek:__,~
"One being's junk is another's art." Motto of Pipes (Autobot warrior, from Transformers: Generation 1).
User avatar
KevLa
 
Posts: 8878
Joined: Sun Sep 05, 2010 7:45 am
Location: Twelve o' clock high.

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby JimInks » Wed Apr 13, 2016 11:53 pm

Rimboche A.P.

The flu-cured gold leaf Virginias are a little grassy with a minor earth note, and mild amount of citrus and fruit. The Acadian perique offers tangy pepper with a little prune and fig, and are evident in every single puff as a contrasting supporting player. The tobaccos meld well to create a very consistent flavor with a slight smokey quality, and is more a dry smoke rather than a sweet one. There are no toppings. The nic-hit is moderate. The strength and taste are mild to medium. Dry out of the tin, I recommend a little hydration for best effect. It brings out the flavors a little more, and slows the burn rate a mite. Requires almost no relights as it easily burns to ash, leaving no moisture in the bowl. I’ve smoked bowls without a relight. Has no dull or harsh spots, and will not bite. Has a nice peppery, slightly woody after taste, and makes nice clouds of smoke.
User avatar
JimInks
 
Posts: 14800
Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2013 8:34 pm

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby KevLa » Thu Apr 14, 2016 6:25 am

Another great review, Jim. It's appreciated. Oh, so many wonderful blends to try! :D
Kev-La :ugeek:__,~
"One being's junk is another's art." Motto of Pipes (Autobot warrior, from Transformers: Generation 1).
User avatar
KevLa
 
Posts: 8878
Joined: Sun Sep 05, 2010 7:45 am
Location: Twelve o' clock high.

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby JimInks » Thu Apr 14, 2016 6:36 pm

Penhooker:
The flue-cured style gold leaf Virginias is half Canadian. They offer some grass, a touch of earth and wood, and some citrus. I’m not sure what the casing is, but it’s sweet and seems to have a small amount of sugar and perhaps fruit. It's very mildly applied. The nic-hit is moderate. The strength is mild and the taste is mild to medium. Needs hydration to bring out the flavors a little and to slow down the burn rate. Not a complex blend by any means, but it’s a ribbon cut that burns well with a consistent, gentle flavor to the finish. Leaves no moisture in the bowl, won’t bite, and has no dull or harsh spots. Barely needs any relights even when you puff at a normal pace, which I recommend. Has a very pleasant semi-sweet, very light woody after taste. The room note isn’t pungent. Makes lots of smoke, too. Would make a good mixer, although I prefer it as is.
User avatar
JimInks
 
Posts: 14800
Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2013 8:34 pm

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby KevLa » Fri Jul 08, 2016 7:51 am

JimInks wrote:
KevLa wrote:I recently ordered a pound each of Picayune, Rimboché - A.B., and Two Timer - Regular, so these are very useful to me. Thanks, Jim :)


You are very welcome, Kevin. I haven't tried the Picayune, so I'll be interested to hear what you think of it.

I've just got around to submitting a review of it, Jim, if you'd care to take a gander :)
Kev.
Kev-La :ugeek:__,~
"One being's junk is another's art." Motto of Pipes (Autobot warrior, from Transformers: Generation 1).
User avatar
KevLa
 
Posts: 8878
Joined: Sun Sep 05, 2010 7:45 am
Location: Twelve o' clock high.

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby JimInks » Tue Oct 18, 2016 8:26 pm

Here's my reviews of the latest D&R blends in the Raccoon series. They had an initial limited run release in July and should be available by year's end.

D&R Raccoon’s Accent:
The mildly tangy Acadian bright Virginia is processed in the perique style, and is fruity sweet as a major component. The double toasted burley is toasty, nutty, lightly earthy with minor rough and sour, spice notes. The floral, woody, lightly sweet and sour earthy yenidje also has a dry “unflavored soda” essence, and ably competes for attention with the other tobaccos. The nic-hit is almost medium. The strength and taste levels are medium. Won’t bite, and has no dull or harsh moments. The tobacco is a little dry, and I recommend a light hydration. Well blended with some complexity, you’ll notice most every aspect of the tobaccos in every puff. Mildly complex, this mixed cut product burns at a reasonable rate if hydrated, cool and clean with a very consistent sweet and savory flavor from start to finish. Requires few relights, and barely leaves a trace of dampness in the bowl. The after taste is pleasant, and the room note is stronger. Both do linger just a mite. Not an all day smoke for the novice, but experienced smokers may consider it to be one.

D&R Raccoon’s Delight:
The mildly tangy Acadian bright Virginia is processed in the perique style, and is fruity sweet as a major component. The very sweet blonde and double toasted burleys provide a bit of toast, some earth, nuts, wood, and a touch of spice. The double toasted burley also sports a slight rough edge, and dry sour notes. The grassy, tart and tangy citrus, lightly spicy bright Virginia complements and competes with the burleys for attention. Well blended with some richness and complexity, you’ll notice most of the complexities of this blend in virtually every puff. There’s no topping. The nic-hit is mild to medium. The strength and taste levels are medium, but get a tad stronger after the half way point, as does the nicotine. Won’t bite, but I recommend a little hydration and moderate puffing cadence as the tobacco is fairly dry. Once done, this mixed cut manufacture burns clean at a slightly more than middling pace with a very consistent flavor as it easily burns to ash. Requires few relights, and hardly leaves any dampness in the bowl. The sweet and mildly savory pleasant after taste and stronger room notes will linger. Can be an all day smoke for experienced smokers.

D&R Raccoon’s Friend:
The mildly tangy Acadian bright Virginia is processed in the perique style, and is fruity sweet as a major component. The dark mahogany and double toasted burleys are toasty, nutty, woody, and earthy with a smidgeon of spice with a slight rough, sour hit. They are the most obvious components. The earthy, mildly tangy, dark fruit sweet red Virginia is a background player. The lightly applied smoky, woody Cyprian latakia underscores the experience. There’s no topping. You’ll notice nearly all aspects of this complex blend in every puff. The nic-hit is a step closer to medium than it is to mild. The strength and taste levels border on medium. Won’t bite or get harsh, but I recommend a little hydration and slow puffing cadence as the tobacco is fairly dry. Once done, this mixed cut blend burns clean at a slightly more than moderate pace with a very consistent flavor as it easily burns to ash. Requires few relights, and leaves virtually no moisture in the bowl. Has an earthy, woody, lightly sweet after taste and room note, both of which linger a little. Can be an all day smoke.
User avatar
JimInks
 
Posts: 14800
Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2013 8:34 pm

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby JimInks » Mon Dec 05, 2016 10:09 pm

D&R Picayune:
The flue cured gold leaf offers some citrus and grass/hay as the base of the blend, though it’s sublimated by the other tobaccos. The dry, woody, smoky, nutty, earthy lightly peppery dark fired burley melds with the spicy, raisin and fig perique, and the floral, dry, woody, earthy mildly sour, vegetative cigar-like Samsun to create a full bodied, well blended product that can be smoked straight by experienced smokers as well as being used as a mixer. The nic-hit is just above medium. The strength and taste are full. Won’t bite, but may get a little harsh and cigarette-like if puffed fast. It’s dry and benefits from a little hydration. Being a virtual shag cut, it burns quickly with a very clean, consistent flavor. Leaves no moisture in the bowl, and hardly needs a relight. The strong after taste and room notes will linger. Not an all day smoke, and not for the novice. I suggest a small bowl if you smoke it straight.
User avatar
JimInks
 
Posts: 14800
Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2013 8:34 pm

Re: Jim's D&R Reviews.

Postby TigerJack » Sun Jan 22, 2017 1:07 am

Nice review Jim, I do like the Picayune quiet a lot, a full smoke that satisfy' s, as I am not a reviewer that is as good a review as I will ever give LOL, G'Day
"If It Ain't Broke, Don't Fix It"
Clint
User avatar
TigerJack
 
Posts: 2554
Joined: Fri Jan 08, 2010 4:22 am
Location: Arkansas


Return to Pipe Tobacco Reviews

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests

cron